Presidential Decision
How to End World War
Two
To drop or not to drop
President Truman had the task of deciding
how to end the war in the Pacific. He had a great number of advisors
but ultimately the decision had to be his and his alone. He had many
alternatives that were presented to him. There may have been other
alternatives as well. Some of the specifics about the development
of the atomic bomb, a project called the Manhatten Project , the specifications
of the bombs and the actual bombings follows in a slide show or as individual
slides. There is also an Eyes
Only memo that lists some available memos and documents that may assist
you in your decision.
What would you have done if you had
to make the decision about how to end the war?
President Roosevelt began a secret project
and then died in April 1945 just as the war in Europe was ending and the
Allied leaders were shifting their efforts to ending the war in the Pacific.
The final decision about the use of the not so secret weapon was left to
Truman. He had to catch up on the specifics of the bomb just to be
able to make a decision about what to do.
The Manhattan Project was the code-
name given to the wartime, top-secret atomic weapons program. The project
was named after the Manhattan Engineer District of the U.S. Army Corps
of Engineers, based in New York City, where much of the early research
was done. General Leslie R. Groves, a tough, no- nonsense Army Corps of
Engineers officer, was put in charge.
1st nuclear chain reaction
University of Chicago
Enrico Fermi, an Italian physicist working
with a team of fellow scientists at he University of Chicago, built the
first nuclear reactor on a squash court under the stands of
the university's football stadium.
On December 2, 1942, the
world's first self-sustaining, controlled nuclear reaction was achieved:
Fusion of plutonium isotope P-239
Fission of uranium isotope U-235

There were at least two methods that
could be used to produce an explosion, both expensive but possible. Extensive
facilities were built at Oak Ridge,Tenn., and Hanford, Wash., to produce
uranium and plutonium, the fissionable material needed for the bombs. A
central laboratory to design both bombs was established at the so-called
Site Y near Los Alamos, N.M.,with Dr. J. Robert Oppenheimer in charge.
A small city was built in the mountains of New Mexico where several hundred
professors, specialists, workers and their families moved in secrecy.
The first bomb dropped was called Trinity
and from all reports was noticed by the people in New Mexico within a 100
mile radius.
-
The rapid spontaneous fission rate of plutonium
239 necessitated that a different type of bomb be designed.
-
A gun-type bomb would not be fast enough
to work. Before the bomb could be assembled, a few stray neutrons would
have been emitted, and these would start a premature chain reaction‚ leading
to a great reduction in the energy released.
-
Seth Neddermeyer, a scientist at Los Alamos,
developed the idea of using explosive charges to compress a sphere of plutonium
very rapidly to a density sufficient to make it go critical and produce
a nuclear explosion.
-
The Trinity bomb was called Fat Man and
measured 10 feet 8 inches long and 5 feet in diameter. It contained a sphere
of plutonium.
-
Conventional explosives surrounding the
plutoniumwere fired so that the plutonium was compressed into a supercritical
mass,producing a chain reaction and an explosion.
-
Fat Man was tested in the New Mexico desert,
near Alamogordo, on July 16, 1945. A blinding explosion, the world's first
nuclear blast, was equivalent to 18,600 tons of TNT. (The second
“Fat Man” was dropped on Nagasaki August 9, 1945.)
Truman -after determining that the Japanese
would fight to the death - decided to drop the bomb on Hiroshima with a
follow-up warning that a bomb would be dropped every 3 days on the Japanese
islands until Japan capitulated.
The first site chosen was a “virgin”
site for the bomb - one in which the actual power of the bomb could be
accessed.
Little Boy
Uranium
Dropped on Hiroshima August 6, 1945
How it works
-
In essence, the Little Boy design consisted
of a gun that fired one mass of uranium 235 at another mass of uranium
235, thus creating a supercritical mass.
-
A crucial requirement was that the pieces
be brought together in a time shorter than the time between spontaneous
fissions.
-
Once the two pieces of uranium are brought
together, the initiator introduces a burst of neutrons and the chain reaction
begins, continuing until the energy released becomes so great that the
bomb simply blows itself apart.
Impact
-
The uranium bomb, Little Boy, exploded
at 8:16 a.m. Hiroshima time
-
43 seconds after it left the B-29
Enola Gay
-
almost 2,000 feet above the ground.

-
It had a yield equivalent to 20,000
tons of TNT.
-
Everything within four square miles was
destroyed.
-
Instantly Killed: 70,000
-
Instantly Injured: 70,000
-
December 1945 total death toll: 140,000
-
1950 total death toll: 200,000
| Little Boy |
Fat Man |
Length - 10 ft 5 in
Diameter - 29 in
Weight - 9,700 lbs
Yield - 12.5 kiloton
Type - Uranium
Where it was dropped- Hiroshimia |
Length - 10 ft 8 in
Diameter - 5 feet
Weight - 10,000 lbs
Yield - 22 kiloton
Type - Plutonium
Where it was dropped -Nagasaki |
Fat Man - Nagasaki
-
Nagasaki was the secondary target bombed
after the primary target Kokura Arsena was covered with clouds and could
not be bombed
-
Kokura, on the northeast corner of Kyushu,
was chosen as the primary target for Fat Man because it was the enemy's
principal production source for automatic weapons. It was also the site
of the Mitsubishi Steel and Arms Works and was one of the largest shipbuilding
and naval centers in Japan.
-
Nagasaki, the secondary target, was the
third largest city on Kyushu. It was also one of Japan's leading shipbuilding
and repair centers. It was not considered a completely "virgin" target,
however, because it had been bombed many weeks before by Twentieth Air
Force bombers.
-
Niigata was originally considered as a
third target, but it was too far away from the other two cities.
-
Fat Man was dropped on Nagasaki, Japan
on August 9, 1945 from a B- 29 called Bockscar, flown by Major Charles
W. Sweeney .
-
The Great Artiste flown by Major James
I. Hopkins, Jr. was to take pictures
Plutonium
Fat Boy
dropped on Nagasaki - August 9, 1945
Impact
-
The plutonium bomb, Fat Man, exploded 1,650
feet above Nagasaki at 11:01 a.m after it left the B-29 called “Bockscar”
-
It had a force of 21,000 tons of TNT.

-
Everything within three square miles was
destroyed.
-
Instantly Killed: 40,000
-
Instantly Injured: 60,000
-
January 1946 total death toll: 70,000
-
1950 total death toll: 140,000
Alternatives
Dr. Farrington Daniels, the director
of the Met. Lab at the University of Chicago, polled 150 scientists working
on the atomic bomb, in order to get their views on how the bomb should
be used.
These were the choices they could vote
upon:
1. Use the bombs in the manner that,
from a military point of view, is most effective in bringing
about prompt surrender at minimum human cost to U.S.
2. Give a military demonstration in
Japan to be followed by renewed opportunity for surrender before full use
of the weapon is employed.
3. Give an experimental demonstration
in this country, with representatives of Japan present; followed
by a new opportunity to surrender before full use of the weapon is
employed.
4. Withhold military use of the weapon,
but make a public experimental demonstration of its effectiveness.
5. Maintain as secret as possible all
developments of our new weapons and refrain from using them in this
war.
How would you end the war?
1. What decision would you have
made?
2. Where there other alternatives as
well?
3. Which ones were best for the United
States and their allies?
4. Which ones were best for Japan?
5. Justify your answer with facts,
details or examples.
Image
of bomb
US
Invasion Plans
Development
of Atomic Bomb
Details about the following topics
FOREWORD
INTRODUCTION
MANHATTAN
PROJECT INVESTIGATING GROUP
PROPAGANDA
SUMMARY
OF DAMAGES AND INJURIES
MAIN
CONCLUSIONS
SELECTION
OF THE TARGET
DESCRIPTION
OF THE CITIES BEFORE THE BOMBINGS Hiroshima Nagasaki
THE
ATTACKS Hiroshima Nagasaki
GENERAL
COMPARISON OF HIROSHIMA AND NAGASAKI
GENERAL
DESCRIPTION OF DAMAGE CAUSED BY THE ATOMIC EXPLOSIONS
TOTAL
CASUALTIES
NATURE
OF AN ATOMIC EXPLOSION
CHARACTERISTICS OF THE DAMAGE
CAUSED BY THE ATOMIC BOMBS
CALCULATIONS
OF THE PEAK PRESSURE OF THE BLAST WAVE
LONG RANGE BLAST DAMAGE
GROUND SHOCK
SHIELDING,
OR SCREENING, FROM THE BLAST
FLASH
BURN
CHARACTERISTICS
OF INJURIES TO PERSONS
BURNS
MECHANICAL
INJURIES
BLAST
INJURIES
RADIATION
INJURIES
SHIELDING
FROM RADIATION
EFFECTS
OF THE ATOMIC BOMBINGS ON THE INHABITANTS OF THE CITIES
Eye Witness Account
of by Father John A. Siemes, professor of modern philosphy at Tokyo's Catholic
University
Article on the Attitude
of the Japanese in August 1945
Potsdam Proclaimation
Oakridge Memo
requesting Truman not drop the bomb
Ralph Bard Memo requesting
Truman not drop the bomb
Target Committee
Memo
Article on Truman's
meeting with Stalin at Potsdam
webmaster
Killeen
Harker Heights Connections
Harker
Heights High School